Gas vs. Wood-Burning Fireplaces: Which Is Right for You?

There’s nothing quite like a fire to bring warmth, comfort, and ambiance to your home. But when it comes time to install, replace, or update your fireplace, one big question comes up fast:

Should you go with gas or wood?

Both gas and wood-burning fireplaces have their pros and cons. The right choice depends on your lifestyle, budget, heating needs, and how you like to enjoy a fire. Here’s a side-by-side look to help you decide.

⸻

🔥 The Charm of Wood-Burning Fireplaces

There’s a reason people romanticize a real wood fire. It’s primal, cozy, and creates an experience that’s hard to replicate.

Pros:

• Authentic experience – crackling logs, natural flames, smoky aroma

• Great during power outages – no electricity required

• Affordable fuel – especially if you cut or source your own wood

• More heat output – when combined with a quality insert or stove

Cons:

• More maintenance – chimneys must be cleaned regularly

• Requires firewood – storage, chopping, stacking, drying

• Slower startup – more effort to light and keep going

• Needs a good draft – or you may get smoke indoors

⸻

🔥 The Ease of Gas Fireplaces

Gas fireplaces offer convenience, cleanliness, and style—without the mess of real wood.

Pros:

• Instant on/off – flip a switch or use a remote

• Low maintenance – no ash, wood, or chimney sweeping (though vented units still need inspection)

• Cleaner burn – fewer particulates and emissions

• Flexible design – many options for inserts, logs, and linear styles

Cons:

• Less heat – especially if it’s decorative-only (ventless units are warmer but have restrictions)

• Higher installation cost – especially if gas lines need to be run

• No real wood feel – can look artificial or less atmospheric

• Relies on gas utility – not ideal during outages unless you have a backup system

⸻

🏡 Which Fireplace Is Right for You?

Ask yourself a few questions:

• Do you want a real fire experience or just ambiance?

→ If you want the full sensory experience: wood. If you’re after clean and simple: gas.

• Are you okay with regular maintenance?

→ Wood fires need sweeping, storage, and setup. Gas is more hands-off.

• Do you need strong heat output?

→ Modern wood stoves and inserts are extremely efficient. Some gas units can heat well, but many are more decorative.

• Is convenience more important than tradition?

→ If you’re busy or want a quick fire at the push of a button: gas is the way to go.

⸻

🧱 What About Inserts and Conversions?

Already have a traditional fireplace? You may be able to:

• Add a gas insert for easy use and better efficiency

• Install a wood stove insert to upgrade heat output

• Seal it off entirely if you’re not using it

A certified professional can assess your chimney, flue, and setup to guide you toward the safest and most effective solution.

⸻

Let Us Help You Find the Right Fit

At Canterbury Chimney, we’ve helped hundreds of Rochester homeowners choose, clean, and maintain fireplaces of all kinds. Whether you’re a lifelong fan of wood-burning warmth or curious about switching to gas, we’re happy to walk you through your options and make sure your setup is safe, efficient, and just right for your home.

👉 Ready to explore your options? Contact us today.